Top Pick Trading Forum

Thank you Eric! That makes sense and is very helpful

Hey Eric, I hope you had a great Christmas! I've been going through and reviewing the lessons to shore up some things. After reviewing the reversal bars, I have a question. In the article you wrote on Mack's site and I think Al Brooks mentions it too, that you want to see "A lower tail that is no ...

I've been doing a similar exercise of going through all of 2019 and marking up the charts. Have you compared the results to Mack's markings to judge improvement? This is something I've been doing and expect to continue doing. Yeah, I'm currently going through the 2022 charts and comparing that to ...

Thanks. Sorry if I posted in the wrong section. Anyone else care to chime in with their experience with resonance breathing? Or any mindfulness/meditation techniques that would fall in the same bucket? I’m curious to hear how effective these practices have been for others. I've been doing the r ...

Thanks chrundle. I am assuming this exercise and the time invested must have really helped with your trading as well? It's still an ongoing process, but things are definitely improving. Going through and marking trades I want to be taking has helped solidify what I'm looking for and when. It's also ...

Hey Guys, I went through the 2019 charts and marked up every red/blue trade and saved them as individual images. This could be useful in looking through lots of trades fast, you can also use a program like Digikam to "tag" images so you can go through the trades and mark which ones fit your plan and ...

Hello! After my last post I've been thinking a lot about a mechanical trading plan and trying to wrap my head around how this journey will go. I understand the basic idea of start simple and iterating over and had no problem with that, but as things got more complicated, I found myself getting more ...

Sorry Eric, I meant 4.8 Edge. I definitely understand 4.9 and how the analysis is independent of the rest of the chart. I think I get it now. I've been working on a trading plan for a while and was getting overwhelmed trying to cover the different nuances. I started simple enough, but was running ...

There's also the derivation of edge table. Under binary decisions, it talks about market state. And in 4.9, when you go bar x bar, it seems more like you're reading the chart using the tools taught. Which all seems to align under the fairly mechanical system. So there's a lot of talk about fairly ...

Hey Eric, sorry I edited my post above after you responded., I'll post below. What's still confusing me a bit is lesson 5.4. It talks about studying static charts and your trades marked should be able to match Mack 90%+ and then talks about Simulation/Live market training. It mentions staying in sim ...